|
glass insulators |
porcelain insulators |
|
glass insulators are made of toughened glass which helpsto prevent the cracks formation in the insulators. |
porcelain insulators are made of ceramic materialsi.e.china clay,quarts,aluminum silicate,plastickaolin, feldspar). |
|
little bit weaker than porcelain. |
mechanically strong. |
|
high dielectric strength (140kv/cm). |
less dielectric strength (60kv/cm). |
|
low compressive strength (10,000kg/cm’). |
high compressive strength (70,000kg/cm'). |
|
high tensile strength (35,000kg/cm'). |
low tensile strength (500kg/cm'). |
|
less effect of temperature and not heated up in the sunlight. |
lesser effect of temperature but offers self-healingsupport. |
|
there is a risk of leakage current due to moisture andraindrops condensed and stagnating on the glass surface. |
moisture and raindrops do not settle on the surfacehence, there is no chance of leakage current insidethe porcelain. |
|
faults can be easily spotted externally because of thetransparent designcompared to the porcelain.e.g.obvious failure can be spotted with glass shattering. |
faults can't be easily found externally as they are notclear and transparent like glass insulators. |
|
as the outer surface is smooth and transparent, there is alittle chance of formation of dusty layers. |
the dust layers formed over time as the outer surfaceis not smooth and transparent as compared to glass. |
|
because of the transparency,the air-bubble and otherimpurities can be easily detected. |
impurities can't be seen easily due to the nontransparent design and material. |
|
they offer excellent pollution withstand performance ascompared to porcelain. |
the pollution withstands performance is not thatimpressive. |
|
the mechanical andelectricalproperties andcharacteristics remain the same over a long time ofservice. |
electrical and echanicscharacteristicsandproperties change by ageing. |
|
high specific resistance and low coefficient of thermalexpansion. |
low specific resistance. |
|
glass insulators |
porcelain insulators |
|
short lifespan than porcelain but has a good servicehistory. |
long service and lifespan with good service history. |
|
they are homogeneous(same material used externallyand internally). |
they are not homogeneous(the outer and innermaterial is different). |
|
looks beautiful. |
don't have a good impact on beautification. |
|
they are light in weight. |
they are heavy. |
|
complex transportation with extra care. |
easy transportation. |
|
easy installation (same procedure). |
easy installation. |
|
used for high voltage ratings. |
used for high voltage ratings. |
|
due to the high dielectric strength,they are easy todesign. |
they are relatively complex to design. |
|
they can't be designed in asymmetrical and irregularshapes. |
they are possible to design in an irregular shape. |
|
lesser costly than porcelain. |
less costly. |
|
mostly used in the uk,sweden, russia, canada & us etc. |
popular and used often in asia and africa. |
|
excellent pollution withstand performance |
less effective in polluted environments |
|
shorter lifespan than porcelain insulators |
longer service lifespan than glass insulators |
glass insulators provide key advantages in dielectric strength, tensile strength, pollution performance and ease of fault detection, making them preferable for certain high-voltage applications.